Despite my highly enjoyable first visit to the basement of the Breakfast and Dessert House in Philadelphia, I still did not expect this second show there to be as fantastic as it was. The ambiance of the basement is a perfect mix of dinginess and coziness, full of friends past, present, and future. Nick and company put together a good mix of acoustic music, astoundingly good considering they assembled it in a week’s time. It was one of those shows where everyone was really hanging out in between bands, not just lingering near each other. It felt so comfortable that I decided to indulge my friend Scotty’s insistence that I learn and play Bad Religion’s “Ten in 2010″ in belated honor of the New Year. I played the song to an outlandishly enthusiastic singalong.
I also played “Frostbite,” which I haven’t played much in the past year. I always thought that song would be best with a hearty singalong, and this show proved me right. Back when I started writing music, I used to have heavy anxiety when people sang along to my songs. It made me self-conscious that anyone was actually paying enough attention to the lyrics to memorize them, or listening to the songs enough times to inadvertently absorb them. Nowadays, I really crave the singalongs. In the moments when I’m not the only one singing, I feel like we take a major step toward breaking down the barrier between performer and audience and we become a group of people singing a song we all know. I enjoy this just as much when someone else is the songleader. I don’t need the glory of being the one who wrote the song; I just want us to sing together.
The day before, I went to church in my hometown for the first time in years. The service included several unison prayers and a handful of hymns, both of which are common to most church services. Speaking in unison is just creepy to me, the essence of cultish groupthink handed down from on high. Singing hymns, however, is more transcendent. If I’m alone, I don’t sing hymns because I am not a man of faith. But I have no problem singing spiritual songs with others because we, whether as a community or as a contrived group of people, desire to feel the power of our numbers and the energy that comes from that. Reciting words that are not my own sounds monotonous and thoughtless. Singing words that are not my own still feels exuberant, because singing with others just feels outstanding to me. The lyrics have to be profoundly stupid or pretty offensive to derail my exuberance. Hell, they can even be profoundly stupid and I’ll still enjoy the experience.
In the DIY scene, or the punk scene, or whatever you wanna call it, our songs are our common language and our cultural currency, and I’ll gladly sing along to a song that I don’t necessarily find inspiring if it means I can sing with 5, 10, or 100 other people. The basement show is our house of worship, and we understand that singing along doesn’t obligate a person to espouse every word of the song in question. If it did, no one would ever sing along to anything. It just celebrates that we have a common bond within the diversity of our ideas. And hey, singing just feels real good.
I finished off my last song, and after some shouting for “one more!”, I decided to sing “We’ll Always Be Home.” I’ve never ended a set with that song since I sing it a cappella, which seems a little weak for a final song, but I was feeling so good I figured, “Why not?” I started singing, and I was shocked at how many people were singing every word with me. When I started Attica! Attica!, this was the highest possible success I could imagine. To encourage more singing along, I tried to write songs that were still thoughtful but a little less wordy than my previous bands. I didn’t really succeed at that (I’m a verbose dude), but I still hoped that these songs could provide a foundation for a hearty and fulfilling singalong. This Philly show was the realization of that idea, and it felt really, really good. I don’t know if I’ve felt that good playing live since Marathon’s last show.
So thank you, Philly. And thank you to anyone who’s ever sung along or written a song for me to sing along to. I now have accomplished everything I wanted to do with Attica! Attica! I’m by no means done (I have a few projects in the pipe as we speak). It’s just that everything that happens from now on is gravy.